Integrating insights from psychology, sociology, and other social sciences is crucial for developing more accurate economic theories. Effective economic policy requires not just good ideas, but compelling narratives that instill confidence and shape expectations. Narrative economics. People tend to think in nominal rather than real (inflation-adjusted) terms, leading to systematic errors in economic decision-making. This contradicts the neoclassical view that wages should always adjust to clear labor markets.

Book Review: Why “Animal Spirits” Still Explain Today’s Markets

Chapter 10 is about why people don’t consider the future rationally in their decisions about savings. Chapter 2 is about the desire for fairness, an emotional drive that can cause people to make decisions that aren’t in their economic best interests. Developed from the 1700s, classical economics proposed economic actors to behave as unemotional rational beings.

Political leaders may rise and fall based on their ability to inspire followers with stories. Literary critics who analyze story patterns find that most of the world’s thousands of stories fit a few simple patterns. Plus, people resist wage cuts when prices drop, even at the cost of their jobs. Yet, debt covenants, wage contracts, and even corporate financial statements often don’t include inflation adjustments. Milton Friedman disagreed and said workers were not subject to money illusion and did take inflation into account in wage negotiations. Surely, the nominal value was the same, but inflation had eroded its real purchasing power.

Further reading

Akerlof and Shiller’s insights are both relevant and accessible, making this book a significant contribution to the understanding of economic dynamics in the 21st century. However, some critics argue that the book’s framework might oversimplify the complexities of economic behavior and that the proposed solutions may not be easily implementable. “Animal Spirits” is a thought-provoking and timely exploration of the psychological factors that underpin economic behavior. Akerlof and Shiller argue that understanding these animal spirits is crucial for policymakers, business leaders, and economists in making sense of the complexities of modern capitalism. George A. Akerlof, the winner of the 2001 Nobel Prize in economics, is a professor at the University of California Berkeley.

Animal spirits drive economic behavior beyond rational calculations

The authors also explore corruption, money illusion, animal spirits and narratives—the stories societies tell about markets, housing, and prosperity. “The authors are right in pointing out the inadequacy of conventional economics in understanding, not to say addressing, today’s economic woes, because they fail to take into account these animal spirits.”—Wan Lixin, Shanghai Daily “With Animal Spirits we hone in on how incentives and narratives can be created to channel the human psychological factor into collectively healthy directions, and how to be aware of the fictions we tell ourselves about how we wish the world and greed and financial security worked. Animal Spirits sheds light on complex issues and leaves readers with a better grasp of undercurrents and—most importantly—a rediscovered belief in principles of common sense and caution.”—Daily Kos Like Keynes, Akerlof and Shiller know that managing these animal spirits requires the steady hand of government—simply allowing markets to work won’t do it. From acclaimed economists George Akerlof and Robert Shiller, the case for why government is needed to restore confidence in the economy Akerlof’s innovative approach to economics has influenced policy discussions and academic research, encouraging a more nuanced understanding of market dynamics and economic phenomena.

How does Animal Spirits address the concept of money illusion?

“In an intriguing new book, Animal Spirits, US economists George Akerlof and Robert Shiller argue that psychology plays a far bigger role in determining economic outcomes than economists realize—and that, broadly speaking, people get what they expect. If we think good times are ahead, we act confidently in a way that creates them. And if we expect a downturn ahead, we act defensively and unwittingly ensure that’s what we get.”—Tim Colebatch, The Age “Another contribution to the human-nature-ensures-economics-is-irrational school of thought. But, unlike many of the rants against people trying to make an honest profit, this is a measured examination of how the present crisis is explained in economic terms. And so it should be. George Akerlof is a Nobel prizewinner, Robert Shiller teaches at Yale and is the author of Irrational Exuberance, which should give you an idea of this one’s approach. This fascinating work uses economics to explain real-life issues, such as real estate price cycles, to key policy problems, such as the relationship between inflation and employment.”—Stephen Matchett, The Australian “The two superstars have produced a truly innovative and bold work that attempts to show how psychological factors explain the origins of the current mess and offer clues for possible solutions. At a time when plummeting confidence is dragging down the market and the economy, the authors’ focus on the psychological aspect of economics is incredibly important.”—Michael Mandel, BusinessWeek In rebuilding the case for a more robust, behaviorally informed Keynesianism, they detail the most pervasive effects of animal spirits in contemporary economic life—such as confidence, fear, bad faith, corruption, a concern for fairness, and the stories we tell ourselves about our economic fortunes—and show how Reaganomics, Thatcherism, and the rational expectations revolution failed to account for them.Animal Spirits offers a road map for reversing the financial misfortunes besetting us today. In this book, acclaimed economists George Akerlof and Robert Shiller challenge the economic wisdom that got us into this mess, and put forward a bold new vision that will transform economics and restore prosperity.Akerlof and Shiller reassert the necessity of an active government role in economic policymaking by recovering the idea of animal spirits, a term John Maynard Keynes used to describe the gloom and despondence that led to the Great Depression and the changing psychology that accompanied recovery. In the book, the authors examine the role of emotions and human psychology in shaping economic decisions and influencing market outcomes.

MoneyScience – Financial Intelligence for the Business World

The first quarter divides animal spirits into five categories. Good notes and a bibliography are a guide to the literature that the book aims to tie together. Even more than Akerlof and Shiller could have hoped, therefore, it is a fine book at exactly the right time. A little awkwardly, the authors have tacked an excellent postscript, about what needs to be done, on a chapter about monetary policy. The book was mostly written before the crisis became acute. The current breakdown, possibly the worst since the Great Depression, was a shock to all but a handful of economists.

The answer in each case is partly, and sometimes mainly, animal spirits Why does the property market go through cycles? Why are financial prices so volatile?

• His collaborative work with Robert Shiller in “Animal Spirits” explores the role of human behavior in economic decision-making.
• Chapter by chapter, the analysis is fascinating and usually persuasive.
• Akerlof and Shiller argue convincingly that animal spirits give a richer and truer account of economic fluctuations.

Minority poverty persists due to complex socio-economic factors

Emotions have a strong presence in economic decision making. Economic performance is largely mental, though not necessarily rational. Akerlof’s and Shiller’s distinguished reputations command attention, and we confirm that their book is worthwhile reading. At issue is whether a psychologically enriched standard model would be too complex to offer useful simplifications.

Money illusion affects economic decision-making and policy

• Traditional economic theory assumes people make purely rational, self-interested decisions.
• The book delves into the concept of “animal spirits,” a term coined by John Maynard Keynes, which refers to the emotions, instincts, and irrational factors that influence economic decisions.
• Workers strongly resist nominal wage cuts, even when economic conditions might warrant them, due to perceptions of unfairness.

During the ’20s, stories of big market wins drove people to speculate in stocks. A run on the banks occurred as people spread stories of financial fragility. Yet, conventional economists ignore stories and even imply that there is something disreputable about basing the economic analysis on stories.

“This very book seems to be one of the ‘must-reads’ in the Obama administration.”—Andreas Ernst, JASSS “Animal Spirits really applies to all the big areas where we need change.”—Peter Orszag, Obama budget director (quoted from, Time Critics noted its focus on the 2008 financial crisis may date the content.

What role does fairness play in wage-setting according to Animal Spirits?

The authorsrecognize how Keynes’s views were stripped of their psychological values, butdo not recognize that the same was done to Smith. Smith’s work contained many noneconomicmotivations for behavior. Stories build the narrative of events, whichdefines and motivates human behavior.

Akerlof’s research has significantly contributed to the field of behavioral economics, challenging traditional economic models by incorporating psychological and sociological factors. Effective economic policy must account for the full range of human motivations and behaviors, not just narrow economic rationality. For example, modest inflation can “grease the wheels” of labor markets by allowing real wage adjustments without nominal cuts. These include confidence, fairness, corruption, money illusion, and stories.

Nominal sums of money thus seem to matter much too much to us. The authors analyze the cases of the last three big recessions in the United States, where each time corruption played a major role in ending the economic growth. People are, concerning large parts of the economy, unaware of what is good or bad for them, and there are cases where they are intentionally misinformed about what they buy (this is snake-oil, supposed to cure everything, but actually ineffective). There are incentives to profit from the trustful people that are overly enthusiastic from the hype and believe in an everlasting growth.

Related News and Events

Until recently, people told stories of rousing innovation about these instruments. After the 1929 crash, stories of unfair or corrupt market manipulation abounded. Conventional economics seeks demonstrable, quantitative facts. These stories are fundamental to the way people think. “The crisis was not foreseen, and is still not fully understood…because there have been no principles in conventional economic theories regarding animal spirits.”